{"schema_version":"claim-reader-v1","record":{"available_versions":[1],"current_version":1,"assessment_summary":"consistent","claim":{"statement":"Every closed topological three-manifold admits a smooth structure compatible with its topology.","id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","slug":"poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1,"kind":"theorem","title":"Smoothing a topological three-manifold","assumptions":["This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."],"scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1"],"formal_declarations":[]},"sha256":"d5194c1d36b8d45326ac332c285fc2047d4d0b33cd58ef1a2c7e23755cb3b423","contexts":[{"assessment_history":[{"report_id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","source_label":"Established result in cited source","state":"resolved","scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"}],"problem_id":"problem-poincare-conjecture","slug":"poincare-conjecture","title":"Poincaré conjecture","publication_version":13,"relationship":{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1},"relation":"supporting_result","relationship_note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1"],"independent_review":"pending","reading":{"placement":"background","note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."}},"assessments":[{"report_id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","source_label":"Established result in cited source","state":"resolved","scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"}],"connections":[],"related_claims":[],"progress":[],"tasks":[],"statements":[{"statement":"Every closed topological three-manifold admits a smooth structure compatible with its topology.","id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","slug":"poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1,"kind":"theorem","title":"Smoothing a topological three-manifold","assumptions":["This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."],"scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1"],"formal_declarations":[],"relation":"supporting_result","relationship_note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1"],"independent_review":"pending","reading":{"placement":"background","note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."}}],"entries":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","source_version_id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","item_id":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","wording":"Milnor distinguishes topological from smooth classification and explains why the distinctions disappear in dimension three. A homology sphere alone does not satisfy the Poincaré hypothesis.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","item_id":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","wording":"The authors report Lean proofs of the smooth theorem and Moise smoothing, yielding the topological theorem. Their release v0.1.3 report names commit 7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3 and audits the endpoint closures for the three standard Lean axioms, without sorryAx or project axioms.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","supersedes":null}],"sources":[{"work":{"authors":["John Milnor"],"kind":"official_description","publication":"published","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[]},"id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","source_id":"milnor-poincare-description","title":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","owner":"John Milnor","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","subject_scope":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","revision":"clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","attribution":"John Milnor","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["Ziyang Qin","Yuan Liao","Ayush Khaitan","Bennett Chow"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"preprint","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"self_reported","ai_note":"Authors report automated assistance; OpenMath has not independently assessed that workflow.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2026-09-27"}},"id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","owner":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","subject_scope":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","revision":"arxiv-2609.33842v1","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","attribution":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90}]}],"assessments":[{"report_id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","source_label":"Established result in cited source","state":"resolved","scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"}],"sources":[{"work":{"authors":["Ziyang Qin","Yuan Liao","Ayush Khaitan","Bennett Chow"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"preprint","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"self_reported","ai_note":"Authors report automated assistance; OpenMath has not independently assessed that workflow.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2026-09-27"}},"id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","owner":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","subject_scope":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","revision":"arxiv-2609.33842v1","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","attribution":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["John Milnor"],"kind":"official_description","publication":"published","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[]},"id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","source_id":"milnor-poincare-description","title":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","owner":"John Milnor","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","subject_scope":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","revision":"clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","attribution":"John Milnor","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90}],"entries":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","source_version_id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","item_id":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","wording":"Milnor distinguishes topological from smooth classification and explains why the distinctions disappear in dimension three. A homology sphere alone does not satisfy the Poincaré hypothesis.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","item_id":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","wording":"The authors report Lean proofs of the smooth theorem and Moise smoothing, yielding the topological theorem. Their release v0.1.3 report names commit 7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3 and audits the endpoint closures for the three standard Lean axioms, without sorryAx or project axioms.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","supersedes":null}],"formalizations":[],"tasks":[],"assessment_state":"proved","publication":{"version":9,"sha256":"590c189aa6a58b52d0f94fc816d0b8e1e9c9e9f9a6aa8e2931846ef6937d893b","published_at":"2026-10-13T19:35:03.794594+00:00","reason":"Reviewed reader correction: preserve assertion history, exact citations and scoped assessments; task evidence names its exact Claim target.","withdrawn":false,"draft":{"reader_guide":{"reading":[{"entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","role":"introduction","note":"Read the setting and notation before comparing the results."},{"entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1","role":"proof","note":"Read the mathematical argument; inspect its Claim for assessment and scope."},{"entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","role":"formal_source","note":"Inspect the formal statement, assumptions and reported checks."},{"entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","role":"formal_source","note":"Inspect the formal statement, assumptions and reported checks."}],"definitions":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture-definition","term":"Closed and simply connected","explanation":"Closed means compact without boundary. Simply connected means path connected with every loop contractible; the question concerns three-dimensional manifolds.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1"]}],"proofs":[],"bounds":[],"witnesses":[],"contributors":{"summary":"Grigori Perelman proved the three-dimensional conjecture through Ricci flow, building on Richard Hamilton’s program. The two linked formalization projects self-report automated assistance; their 2026 work formalizes an established theorem.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"]},"scopes":[{"id":"poincare-three-topological-scope-detail","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},"label":"The topological three-dimensional Poincaré theorem","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"]},{"id":"poincare-three-smooth-scope-detail","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2},"label":"The smooth three-dimensional theorem","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"]},{"id":"poincare-smooth-four-scope-detail","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-smooth-four","version":1},"label":"The smooth four-dimensional Poincaré question","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1"]},{"id":"poincare-topological-four-scope-detail","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-topological-four","version":1},"label":"The topological four-dimensional theorem","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1"]}]},"representations":[{"hash_profile":"rfc8785","schema_version":"visual-representation-v1","id":"poincare-dimension-category","version":1,"subject":{"kind":"problem","id":"problem-poincare-conjecture","sha256":"f3c6e992d6aa7860811745b12312b3140953ec399c98f543cdaca6ab4dfa0cf4"},"purpose":"setup","title":"Dimension and the meaning of “the same sphere”","caption":"The three-dimensional question is settled. In dimension four, the smooth requirement remains a separate open question.","description":"A two-by-two map compares dimension three and dimension four, with homeomorphism in the topological column and diffeomorphism in the smooth column. Both dimension-three statements and the topological dimension-four statement are proved in the cited sources; the smooth dimension-four statement is open.","assumptions":["All manifolds here are closed.","Dimension three assumes simple connectivity; the four-dimensional questions assume homotopy equivalence to S⁴."],"limitation":"The rows have different hypotheses. A homeomorphism is not a diffeomorphism; the four-dimensional smooth question is not an unfinished part of the three-dimensional theorem. This is a scope map, not a geometric picture of S³ or a proof.","author":"OpenMath source curation","authoring_method":"ai_assisted_curation","authored_on":"2026-10-12","independent_review":"pending","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"],"payload":{"kind":"cases_map","row_heading":"Dimension","rows":[{"id":"three","label":"Dimension 3"},{"id":"four","label":"Dimension 4"}],"columns":[{"id":"topological","label":"Topological · homeomorphism"},{"id":"smooth","label":"Smooth · diffeomorphism"}],"cells":[{"id":"three-topological","row":"three","column":"topological","label":"Homeomorphic to S³","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2}},{"id":"three-smooth","row":"three","column":"smooth","label":"Diffeomorphic to S³","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2}},{"id":"four-topological","row":"four","column":"topological","label":"Homeomorphic to S⁴","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-topological-four","version":1}},{"id":"four-smooth","row":"four","column":"smooth","label":"Diffeomorphic to S⁴?","claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-smooth-four","version":1}}],"empty_label":"No result indexed in this selection"}}],"visuals":[{"representation":{"id":"poincare-dimension-category","version":1},"section":"question"}],"claim_relations":[{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},"relation":"primary_formulation","relationship_note":"Compact Hausdorff three-manifolds without boundary; simply connected includes connectedness.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:0:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2},"relation":"equivalent_formulation","relationship_note":"Smoothness is additional structure; in dimension three the classification agrees with the topological theorem via smoothing and uniqueness of smooth structures.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-three-smooth:v1"],"independent_review":"pending","reading":{"placement":"formulation","note":"Smoothness is additional structure; in dimension three the classification agrees with the topological theorem via smoothing and uniqueness of smooth structures."}},{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1},"relation":"supporting_result","relationship_note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1"],"independent_review":"pending","reading":{"placement":"background","note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."}},{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-finite-extinction","version":1},"relation":"supporting_result","relationship_note":"Extinction concerns the flow with surgery, including discarded components; it does not mean that the original manifold vanishes under a homeomorphism.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-finite-extinction:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-smooth-four","version":1},"relation":"related_variant","relationship_note":"This is a separate conjecture in dimension four; simple connectivity alone is insufficient for its hypothesis.","result":"unproved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-smooth-four:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-topological-four","version":1},"relation":"related_variant","relationship_note":"Freedman’s topological conclusion does not identify a smooth structure or imply the smooth four-dimensional conjecture.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-topological-four:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"}],"connections":[{"id":"poincare-smooth-versus-topological-four","source":{"id":"claim-poincare-topological-four","version":1},"target":{"id":"claim-poincare-smooth-four","version":1},"relation":"related_to","assertion":null,"explanation":"Homeomorphism and diffeomorphism are different requirements in dimension four.","limitation":"The proved topological theorem does not settle the smooth conjecture.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"id":"poincare-three-four-scope","source":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},"target":{"id":"claim-poincare-smooth-four","version":1},"relation":"analogue_of","assertion":null,"explanation":"The four-dimensional smooth question concerns a different dimension and equivalence notion.","limitation":"The three-dimensional theorem is fully proved; this analogue is not an unresolved part of it.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"}],"milestones":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture:milestone:question","date":{"value":"1904"},"date_basis":"publication","category":"foundation","title":"Poincaré poses the question","summary":"The loop-contraction question becomes the three-dimensional conjecture.","limitation":"Historical mathematics, external formal reports and OpenMath verification are separate evidence.","claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2}],"source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:milestone:extinction","date":{"value":"2003-07-17"},"date_basis":"preprint","category":"related_result","title":"Perelman’s finite-extinction argument","summary":"The final preprint supplies extinction for the relevant Ricci flows with surgery.","limitation":"Historical mathematics, external formal reports and OpenMath verification are separate evidence.","claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-finite-extinction","version":1}],"source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:milestone:account","date":{"value":"2007"},"date_basis":"publication","category":"related_result","title":"A detailed proof account","summary":"Morgan and Tian publish the proof and three-sphere conclusion.","limitation":"Historical mathematics, external formal reports and OpenMath verification are separate evidence.","claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2}],"source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:milestone:qin","date":{"value":"2026-09-27"},"date_basis":"preprint","category":"formalization","title":"A source-pinned Lean formalization report","summary":"The authors report smooth and topological proofs with release-specific endpoint audits.","limitation":"Historical mathematics, external formal reports and OpenMath verification are separate evidence.","claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2}],"source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:milestone:frenzy","date":{"value":"2026-09-28"},"date_basis":"formalization","category":"formalization","title":"External comparator verification is reported","summary":"FrenzyMath records statement and kernel checks at its named proof commit.","limitation":"Historical mathematics, external formal reports and OpenMath verification are separate evidence.","claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2}],"source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2"],"independent_review":"pending"},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:milestone:frenzypaper","date":{"value":"2026-10-06"},"date_basis":"preprint","category":"formalization","title":"An AI-assisted formalization account","summary":"The preprint describes the project and public evidence.","limitation":"Historical mathematics, external formal reports and OpenMath verification are separate evidence.","claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2}],"source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1"],"independent_review":"pending"}],"activities":[{"id":"poincare-external-formalization","title":"Two public formalization projects","kind":"formalization","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2"],"summary":"The selected 2026 projects report complete smooth and topological three-dimensional proofs, with exact release or verification revisions.","limitation":"These source reports do not constitute OpenMath executions or independently reviewed mathematical correspondence.","related_claim_ids":["claim-poincare-three-topological","claim-poincare-three-smooth"]},{"id":"poincare-verification-date-correction","title":"Verification date distinguished from publication date","kind":"source_correction","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2"],"summary":"The project report records checks on 28 September 2026. Its publication date is not established, and that verification event is not used as a bibliographic date.","limitation":"This metadata correction changes no mathematical statement, tested proof commit or externally reported check outcome.","related_claim_ids":["claim-poincare-three-smooth","claim-poincare-three-topological"]}],"curation":{"checked_on":"2026-10-12","selection":"The accepted topological theorem, smooth formulation, proof ingredients, dimension-four scope and recent formalization evidence.","search_scope":"Clay’s official description and Morgan–Tian account; Perelman’s finite-extinction paper; Manolescu’s 2026 survey; two 2026 formalization papers, exact public source revisions and the FrenzyMath verification report; Mathlib wanted declarations.","formal_status":"Complete Lean proofs of the topological and smooth three-dimensional statements are reported by two external projects. Links below pin the relevant source revisions. Mathlib’s wanted declarations remain statement-only at the inspected revision. No OpenMath proof build or independent correspondence review is recorded.","ai_status":"Both formalization projects self-report automated assistance; this attribution is separate from theorem truth and verification evidence.","independent_review":"pending"},"schema_version":"research-record-v3","claims":[{"statement":"Every closed, simply connected topological three-manifold is homeomorphic to the standard three-sphere.","id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","slug":"poincare-three-topological","version":2,"kind":"theorem","title":"The topological three-dimensional Poincaré theorem","assumptions":["Compact Hausdorff three-manifolds without boundary; simply connected includes connectedness."],"scope":"Compact Hausdorff three-manifolds without boundary; simply connected includes connectedness.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"],"formal_declarations":["DifferentialGeometry.Topology.poincare_conjecture","PoincareConjecture.ComparatorTargets.topologicalPoincareSkeleton","SimplyConnectedSpace.nonempty_homeomorph_sphere_three"]},{"statement":"Every closed, simply connected smooth three-manifold is diffeomorphic to the standard smooth three-sphere.","id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","slug":"poincare-three-smooth","version":2,"kind":"theorem","title":"The smooth three-dimensional theorem","assumptions":["Smoothness is additional structure; in dimension three the classification agrees with the topological theorem via smoothing and uniqueness of smooth structures."],"scope":"Smoothness is additional structure; in dimension three the classification agrees with the topological theorem via smoothing and uniqueness of smooth structures.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"],"formal_declarations":["DifferentialGeometry.PDE.RicciFlow.Surgery.Topology.smoothPoincareConjecture_holds","PoincareConjecture.ComparatorTargets.smoothPoincareSkeleton","SimplyConnectedSpace.nonempty_sdiffeomorph_sphere_three"]},{"statement":"Every closed topological three-manifold admits a smooth structure compatible with its topology.","id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","slug":"poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1,"kind":"theorem","title":"Smoothing a topological three-manifold","assumptions":["This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."],"scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1"],"formal_declarations":[]},{"statement":"A closed, oriented, simply connected smooth three-manifold with an initial smooth Riemannian metric admits Ricci flow with surgery that becomes extinct in finite time.","id":"claim-poincare-finite-extinction","slug":"poincare-finite-extinction","version":1,"kind":"theorem","title":"Finite extinction in the simply connected case","assumptions":["Extinction concerns the flow with surgery, including discarded components; it does not mean that the original manifold vanishes under a homeomorphism."],"scope":"Extinction concerns the flow with surgery, including discarded components; it does not mean that the original manifold vanishes under a homeomorphism.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"],"formal_declarations":[]},{"statement":"Every closed smooth four-manifold homotopy equivalent to the four-sphere is diffeomorphic to the standard smooth four-sphere.","id":"claim-poincare-smooth-four","slug":"poincare-smooth-four","version":1,"kind":"conjecture","title":"The smooth four-dimensional Poincaré question","assumptions":["This is a separate conjecture in dimension four; simple connectivity alone is insufficient for its hypothesis."],"scope":"This is a separate conjecture in dimension four; simple connectivity alone is insufficient for its hypothesis.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1"],"formal_declarations":[]},{"statement":"Every closed topological four-manifold homotopy equivalent to the four-sphere is homeomorphic to the four-sphere.","id":"claim-poincare-topological-four","slug":"poincare-topological-four","version":1,"kind":"theorem","title":"The topological four-dimensional theorem","assumptions":["Freedman’s topological conclusion does not identify a smooth structure or imply the smooth four-dimensional conjecture."],"scope":"Freedman’s topological conclusion does not identify a smooth structure or imply the smooth four-dimensional conjecture.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1"],"formal_declarations":[]}],"problem":{"resolution_scope":{"resolution":"proved","extent":"full_statement","summary":"The three-dimensional theorem is proved by Perelman’s work, with detailed proof accounts. Recent sources also report complete Lean formalizations; their exact statements and externally checked revisions are listed separately.","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:0:v1"],"progress_claim_ids":[],"remaining":null},"statement_kind":"theorem","problem_id":"problem-poincare-conjecture","slug":"poincare-conjecture","title":"Poincaré conjecture","question":"Is every closed, simply connected three-dimensional manifold homeomorphic to the three-sphere?","scope":"Closed means compact without boundary. Simply connected includes path connectedness and says every loop can be contracted to a point. The conclusion is a homeomorphism to the standard three-sphere, not an isometry for an arbitrary metric. This is the topological theorem in dimension three.","aliases":["Poincaré conjecture"],"fields":["Topology","Geometry"],"msc":["57K30","57R60"],"topics":["Three-manifolds","Ricci flow with surgery","Formal proof"],"background":"graduate","scale":"known theorem","depth":"maintained","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"],"status_report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:0:v1"],"editorial":{"collection_id":"openmath-pilot","collection_title":"OpenMath pilot collection","reviewer":"OpenMath source curation","state":"known","scope":"The canonical question and cited source selection only.","rationale":"The three-dimensional theorem is proved by Perelman’s work, with detailed proof accounts. Recent sources also report complete Lean formalizations; their exact statements and externally checked revisions are listed separately.","decided_on":"2026-10-12","review_due_on":"2027-01-12","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:0:v1"],"independent_mathematical_review":"pending"},"literature":[{"title":"Ricci Flow and the Poincaré Conjecture","url":"https://www.claymath.org/resource/ricci-flow-and-the-poincare-conjecture/","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."},{"title":"Finite extinction time for the solutions to the Ricci flow on certain three-manifolds","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0307245v1","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."},{"title":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."},{"title":"From Knots to Four-Manifolds","url":"https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/25M1806703","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."},{"title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."},{"title":"An AI-Assisted Formalization of the Poincaré Conjecture","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.08329v1","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."},{"title":"Poincaré comparator integration verification","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a/archive/PoincareConjecture/references/ricci-flow/mapher/integration-verification/README.md","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."},{"title":"Mathlib · wanted Poincaré statements","url":"https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b/Wanted/Geometry/Manifold/PoincareConjecture.lean","note":"See the cited passages and source metadata below for exact scope and revision."}],"formalizations":[{"title":"Topological theorem · DifferentialGeometry release v0.1.3","url":"https://github.com/qinz1yang/differential-geometry/blob/7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3/DifferentialGeometry/Topology/ThreeManifold/Poincare.lean","note":"The preprint reports a complete Lean proof of the exact topological theorem at this release. Endpoint source was inspected; OpenMath has not rebuilt its dependency closure or independently reviewed correspondence.","target":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},"proof_status":"reported_complete","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"],"declaration":"DifferentialGeometry.Topology.poincare_conjecture","source_commit":"7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3","alignment":"candidate","checked_on":"2026-10-12"},{"title":"Smooth theorem · DifferentialGeometry release v0.1.3","url":"https://github.com/qinz1yang/differential-geometry/blob/7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3/DifferentialGeometry/Geometry/Flow/RicciFlow/Surgery/Skeleton/PoincareEndgame.lean","note":"The preprint reports a complete Lean proof at this release. Its formal scope is the smooth three-dimensional theorem; OpenMath has not reproduced the build.","target":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2},"proof_status":"reported_complete","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"],"declaration":"DifferentialGeometry.PDE.RicciFlow.Surgery.Topology.smoothPoincareConjecture_holds","source_commit":"7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3","alignment":"candidate","checked_on":"2026-10-12"},{"title":"Topological theorem · FrenzyMath reported verified revision","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04/PoincareConjecture/Comparator/Solution.lean","note":"Project evidence reports successful statement comparison and Lean/Nanoda verification for this proof commit. The later report revision is cited separately; OpenMath has not rerun these checks or completed independent mathematical review.","target":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},"proof_status":"reported_complete","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2"],"declaration":"PoincareConjecture.ComparatorTargets.topologicalPoincareSkeleton","source_commit":"1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04","alignment":"candidate","checked_on":"2026-10-12"},{"title":"Smooth theorem · FrenzyMath reported verified revision","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04/PoincareConjecture/Comparator/Solution.lean","note":"Project evidence reports successful statement comparison and Lean/Nanoda verification for this proof commit. The later report revision is cited separately; OpenMath has not rerun these checks or completed independent mathematical review.","target":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2},"proof_status":"reported_complete","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2"],"declaration":"PoincareConjecture.ComparatorTargets.smoothPoincareSkeleton","source_commit":"1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04","alignment":"candidate","checked_on":"2026-10-12"},{"title":"Topological statement · Mathlib wanted theorem","url":"https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b/Wanted/Geometry/Manifold/PoincareConjecture.lean","note":"This revision uses proof_wanted for the exact statement. A wanted declaration is not a completed Mathlib proof; the external projects above have separate source and verification evidence.","target":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},"proof_status":"statement_only","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"],"declaration":"SimplyConnectedSpace.nonempty_homeomorph_sphere_three","source_commit":"9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b","alignment":"candidate","checked_on":"2026-10-12"},{"title":"Smooth statement · Mathlib wanted theorem","url":"https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b/Wanted/Geometry/Manifold/PoincareConjecture.lean","note":"This revision uses proof_wanted for the exact statement. A wanted declaration is not a completed Mathlib proof; the external projects above have separate source and verification evidence.","target":{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2},"proof_status":"statement_only","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1"],"declaration":"SimplyConnectedSpace.nonempty_sdiffeomorph_sphere_three","source_commit":"9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b","alignment":"candidate","checked_on":"2026-10-12"}],"related":[],"tasks":[],"insights":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture-meaning","title":"What the theorem identifies","summary":"A closed simply connected three-manifold has the same topology as the three-sphere. The theorem does not require its chosen metric to be round.","review":"pending","kind":"interpretation","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1"],"claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2}],"limitation":"Having the sphere’s homology alone is weaker than being simply connected."},{"id":"poincare-conjecture-flow","title":"Ricci flow, surgery and finite extinction","summary":"The accepted proof follows Hamilton’s geometric evolution, Perelman’s control of singularities and surgery, and finite extinction followed by topological reconstruction.","review":"pending","kind":"approach","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1"],"claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2},{"id":"claim-poincare-finite-extinction","version":1}],"limitation":"This is a reading guide to the cited proof, not a replacement for its analytic and topological arguments."},{"id":"poincare-conjecture-smoothing","title":"From a smooth proof to the topological theorem","summary":"Moise smoothing provides compatible smooth structure, the smooth theorem yields a diffeomorphism to the sphere, and forgetting smooth structure gives a homeomorphism.","review":"pending","kind":"approach","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"],"claims":[{"id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1},{"id":"claim-poincare-three-smooth","version":2},{"id":"claim-poincare-three-topological","version":2}],"limitation":"The smoothing step is dimension-specific; the analogous smooth four-dimensional question remains open."}],"coverage_gaps":["Selected sources and milestones; this is not an exhaustive literature review.","Independent mathematical review and OpenMath reproduction of external proof checks remain pending."],"checked_on":"2026-10-12"},"sources":[{"id":"clay-millennium@observed-2026-10-01","source_id":"clay-millennium","title":"Clay · Millennium Problems","owner":"Clay Mathematics Institute","url":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/","subject_scope":"Seven Millennium Prize Problems; five selected here","revision":"observed-2026-10-01","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual checked import; new observations require staff preview and publication","identifier_policy":"Canonical source URL plus explicit item/declaration locator; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-01","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Not established; links and OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium-problems/","attribution":"Clay Mathematics Institute","rights_note":"Store metadata and original OpenMath paraphrases; follow the original source for authoritative wording.","check_interval_days":30},{"work":{"authors":["John Morgan","Gang Tian"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"published","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2007"}},"id":"morgan-tian-poincare@clay-monograph-3-2007","source_id":"morgan-tian-poincare","title":"Ricci Flow and the Poincaré Conjecture","owner":"John Morgan; Gang Tian","url":"https://www.claymath.org/resource/ricci-flow-and-the-poincare-conjecture/","subject_scope":"Ricci Flow and the Poincaré Conjecture","revision":"clay-monograph-3-2007","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://www.claymath.org/resource/ricci-flow-and-the-poincare-conjecture/","attribution":"John Morgan; Gang Tian","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["Grigori Perelman"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"preprint","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2003-07-17"}},"id":"perelman-extinction@arxiv-math-0307245v1","source_id":"perelman-extinction","title":"Finite extinction time for the solutions to the Ricci flow on certain three-manifolds","owner":"Grigori Perelman","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0307245v1","subject_scope":"Finite extinction time for the solutions to the Ricci flow on certain three-manifolds","revision":"arxiv-math-0307245v1","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0307245v1","attribution":"Grigori Perelman","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["John Milnor"],"kind":"official_description","publication":"published","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[]},"id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","source_id":"milnor-poincare-description","title":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","owner":"John Milnor","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","subject_scope":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","revision":"clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","attribution":"John Milnor","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["Ciprian Manolescu"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"published","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2026"}},"id":"manolescu-four-manifolds@icm-2026-doi-25M1806703","source_id":"manolescu-four-manifolds","title":"From Knots to Four-Manifolds","owner":"Ciprian Manolescu","url":"https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/25M1806703","subject_scope":"From Knots to Four-Manifolds","revision":"icm-2026-doi-25M1806703","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/25M1806703","attribution":"Ciprian Manolescu","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["Ziyang Qin","Yuan Liao","Ayush Khaitan","Bennett Chow"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"preprint","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"self_reported","ai_note":"Authors report automated assistance; OpenMath has not independently assessed that workflow.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2026-09-27"}},"id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","owner":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","subject_scope":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","revision":"arxiv-2609.33842v1","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","attribution":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["Zhiyuan Zhang","Axel Delaval","Leheng Chen","Jinxuan Chen","Jie Xu","Yuxuan Liao","Jiedong Jiang","Chunlei Liu","Bin Dong"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"preprint","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"self_reported","ai_note":"Authors report automated assistance; OpenMath has not independently assessed that workflow.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2026-10-06"}},"id":"frenzymath-poincare@arxiv-2610.08329v1","source_id":"frenzymath-poincare","title":"An AI-Assisted Formalization of the Poincaré Conjecture","owner":"Zhiyuan Zhang; Axel Delaval; Leheng Chen; Jinxuan Chen; Jie Xu; Yuxuan Liao; Jiedong Jiang; Chunlei Liu; Bin Dong","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.08329v1","subject_scope":"An AI-Assisted Formalization of the Poincaré Conjecture","revision":"arxiv-2610.08329v1","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.08329v1","attribution":"Zhiyuan Zhang; Axel Delaval; Leheng Chen; Jinxuan Chen; Jie Xu; Yuxuan Liao; Jiedong Jiang; Chunlei Liu; Bin Dong","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["FrenzyMath contributors"],"kind":"research_project","publication":"project","publication_note":"Project-supplied verification report at the pinned documentation revision. The 28 September date describes verification, not publication; publication date is not established.","ai_role":"self_reported","ai_note":"Authors report automated assistance; OpenMath has not independently assessed that workflow.","artifacts":[{"kind":"formal_code","title":"Reported verified proof revision","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/tree/1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04","version":"1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04","assessment":"external_report","note":"Project reports successful Comparator, Lean and Nanoda checks; OpenMath has not reproduced them."}]},"id":"frenzymath-poincare-verification@432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a-metadata-v2","source_id":"frenzymath-poincare-verification","title":"Poincaré comparator integration verification","owner":"FrenzyMath contributors","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a/archive/PoincareConjecture/references/ricci-flow/mapher/integration-verification/README.md","subject_scope":"Poincaré comparator integration verification","revision":"432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a; bibliographic metadata corrected 2026-10-12","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a/archive/PoincareConjecture/references/ricci-flow/mapher/integration-verification/README.md","attribution":"FrenzyMath contributors","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["Mathlib contributors"],"kind":"research_project","publication":"project","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[]},"id":"mathlib-poincare-wanted@9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b","source_id":"mathlib-poincare-wanted","title":"Mathlib · wanted Poincaré statements","owner":"Mathlib contributors","url":"https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b/Wanted/Geometry/Manifold/PoincareConjecture.lean","subject_scope":"Mathlib · wanted Poincaré statements","revision":"9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b/Wanted/Geometry/Manifold/PoincareConjecture.lean","attribution":"Mathlib contributors","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["FrenzyMath contributors"],"kind":"research_project","publication":"project","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"self_reported","ai_note":"Authors report automated assistance; OpenMath has not independently assessed that workflow.","artifacts":[{"kind":"formal_code","title":"Reported verified proof revision","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/tree/1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04","version":"1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04","assessment":"external_report","note":"Project reports successful Comparator, Lean and Nanoda checks; OpenMath has not reproduced them."}],"published":{"value":"2026-09-28"}},"id":"frenzymath-poincare-verification@432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a","source_id":"frenzymath-poincare-verification","title":"Poincaré comparator integration verification","owner":"FrenzyMath contributors","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a/archive/PoincareConjecture/references/ricci-flow/mapher/integration-verification/README.md","subject_scope":"Poincaré comparator integration verification","revision":"432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a/archive/PoincareConjecture/references/ricci-flow/mapher/integration-verification/README.md","attribution":"FrenzyMath contributors","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90}],"entries":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","source_version_id":"clay-millennium@observed-2026-10-01","item_id":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium/poincare-conjecture/","url":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium/poincare-conjecture/","wording":"Is every closed, simply connected three-dimensional manifold homeomorphic to the three-sphere?","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium/poincare-conjecture/","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","source_version_id":"morgan-tian-poincare@clay-monograph-3-2007","item_id":"Clay monograph 3; introduction, Theorem 0.1 and Corollary 0.2","url":"https://www.claymath.org/resource/ricci-flow-and-the-poincare-conjecture/","wording":"Morgan and Tian give a detailed proof of Perelman’s result, using Ricci flow with surgery and finite-time extinction to obtain the three-sphere conclusion.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"Clay monograph 3; introduction, Theorem 0.1 and Corollary 0.2","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1","source_version_id":"perelman-extinction@arxiv-math-0307245v1","item_id":"Abstract; finite-extinction argument","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0307245v1","wording":"Perelman establishes finite extinction for the relevant three-manifold class under Ricci flow with surgery; the simply connected closed case is used in the Poincaré proof.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"Abstract; finite-extinction argument","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","source_version_id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","item_id":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","wording":"Milnor distinguishes topological from smooth classification and explains why the distinctions disappear in dimension three. A homology sphere alone does not satisfy the Poincaré hypothesis.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1","source_version_id":"manolescu-four-manifolds@icm-2026-doi-25M1806703","item_id":"§3, Conjecture 3.1 and preceding topological classification","url":"https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/25M1806703","wording":"The survey states the smooth four-dimensional Poincaré conjecture as an open question, distinct from Freedman’s topological four-dimensional result.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§3, Conjecture 3.1 and preceding topological classification","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","item_id":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","wording":"The authors report Lean proofs of the smooth theorem and Moise smoothing, yielding the topological theorem. Their release v0.1.3 report names commit 7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3 and audits the endpoint closures for the three standard Lean axioms, without sorryAx or project axioms.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-formal:v1","source_version_id":"frenzymath-poincare@arxiv-2610.08329v1","item_id":"Formal theorem endpoints and verification discussion","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2610.08329v1","wording":"The team reports an AI-assisted Lean formalization of both the smooth and topological three-dimensional theorem, with public verification resources.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"Formal theorem endpoints and verification discussion","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v1","source_version_id":"frenzymath-poincare-verification@432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a","item_id":"Local integration verification; verification.json beside README","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a/archive/PoincareConjecture/references/ricci-flow/mapher/integration-verification/README.md","wording":"The project’s report records successful statement comparison and Lean/Nanoda checks on 28 September 2026 for proof commit 1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04, permitting only the three standard axioms. Later documentation and import commits are not the tested revision; the report is project-supplied evidence.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"Local integration verification; verification.json beside README","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v2","source_version_id":"frenzymath-poincare-verification@432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a-metadata-v2","item_id":"Local integration verification; verification.json beside README","url":"https://github.com/frenzymath/Poincare-Conjecture/blob/432c38f2aa5a30efb13871292d17b4a3309a496a/archive/PoincareConjecture/references/ricci-flow/mapher/integration-verification/README.md","wording":"The project’s report records successful statement comparison and Lean/Nanoda checks on 28 September 2026 for proof commit 1876d7dc2c85325a3f62ce9776af98f910c5db04, permitting only the three standard axioms. Later documentation and import commits are not the tested revision; the report is project-supplied evidence.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"Local integration verification; verification.json beside README","supersedes":"poincare-conjecture:entry:frenzy-verification:v1"},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:wanted-statements:v1","source_version_id":"mathlib-poincare-wanted@9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b","item_id":"SimplyConnectedSpace.nonempty_homeomorph_sphere_three and nonempty_sdiffeomorph_sphere_three","url":"https://github.com/leanprover-community/mathlib4/blob/9454a4c25a2b923eb55dba3098f2d6ae0484d09b/Wanted/Geometry/Manifold/PoincareConjecture.lean","wording":"This Mathlib revision declares the three-dimensional topological and smooth Poincaré statements with proof_wanted. These are formal statements seeking library proofs, not evidence of a completed proof in Mathlib.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"SimplyConnectedSpace.nonempty_homeomorph_sphere_three and nonempty_sdiffeomorph_sphere_three","supersedes":null}],"reports":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture:report:0:v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:0:v1","state":"resolved","source_label":"Solved","scope":"The cited source item and version only; this is not an independent OpenMath assessment.","source_date":null,"observed_on":"2026-10-01","evidence_url":"https://www.claymath.org/millennium/poincare-conjecture/","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-three-smooth:v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:proof:v1","state":"resolved","source_label":"Established result in cited source","scope":"Smoothness is additional structure; in dimension three the classification agrees with the topological theorem via smoothing and uniqueness of smooth structures.","source_date":null,"observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://www.claymath.org/resource/ricci-flow-and-the-poincare-conjecture/","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","state":"resolved","source_label":"Established result in cited source","scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","source_date":null,"observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-finite-extinction:v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:extinction:v1","state":"resolved","source_label":"Established result in cited source","scope":"Extinction concerns the flow with surgery, including discarded components; it does not mean that the original manifold vanishes under a homeomorphism.","source_date":null,"observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/math/0307245v1","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-smooth-four:v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1","state":"reported_open","source_label":"Open question in cited source","scope":"This is a separate conjecture in dimension four; simple connectivity alone is insufficient for its hypothesis.","source_date":null,"observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/25M1806703","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-topological-four:v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:smooth-four:v1","state":"resolved","source_label":"Established result in cited source","scope":"Freedman’s topological conclusion does not identify a smooth structure or imply the smooth four-dimensional conjecture.","source_date":null,"observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://epubs.siam.org/doi/10.1137/25M1806703","supersedes":null}]},"status":{"state":"proved","label":"Proved","extent":"full_statement","summary":"The three-dimensional theorem is proved by Perelman’s work, with detailed proof accounts. Recent sources also report complete Lean formalizations; their exact statements and externally checked revisions are listed separately.","basis":"editorial","attributed_to":"OpenMath pilot collection · OpenMath source curation","as_of":"2026-10-12","progress_label":null,"progress_claim_ids":[],"remaining":null,"views":["resolved"]}},"selected_context":{"assessment_history":[{"report_id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","source_label":"Established result in cited source","state":"resolved","scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"}],"problem_id":"problem-poincare-conjecture","slug":"poincare-conjecture","title":"Poincaré conjecture","publication_version":9,"relationship":{"claim":{"id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1},"relation":"supporting_result","relationship_note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1"],"independent_review":"pending","reading":{"placement":"background","note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."}},"assessments":[{"report_id":"poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","source_label":"Established result in cited source","state":"resolved","scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","observed_on":"2026-10-12","evidence_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","entry_id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1"}],"connections":[],"related_claims":[],"progress":[],"tasks":[],"statements":[{"statement":"Every closed topological three-manifold admits a smooth structure compatible with its topology.","id":"claim-poincare-moise-smoothing","slug":"poincare-moise-smoothing","version":1,"kind":"theorem","title":"Smoothing a topological three-manifold","assumptions":["This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."],"scope":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","source_entry_ids":["poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1"],"formal_declarations":[],"relation":"supporting_result","relationship_note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold.","result":"proved","report_ids":["poincare-conjecture:report:poincare-moise-smoothing:v1"],"independent_review":"pending","reading":{"placement":"background","note":"This existence statement supplies the smooth input for the topological theorem; it alone does not classify the manifold."}}],"entries":[{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:dimension-scope:v1","source_version_id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","item_id":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","wording":"Milnor distinguishes topological from smooth classification and explains why the distinctions disappear in dimension three. A homology sphere alone does not satisfy the Poincaré hypothesis.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§§1–3; dimension-three comparison on page 5","supersedes":null},{"id":"poincare-conjecture:entry:qin-formal:v1","source_version_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","item_id":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","wording":"The authors report Lean proofs of the smooth theorem and Moise smoothing, yielding the topological theorem. Their release v0.1.3 report names commit 7a48598d35109aa99d1cc678e2724c213cdf4ff3 and audits the endpoint closures for the three standard Lean axioms, without sorryAx or project axioms.","wording_kind":"paraphrase","locator":"§1, Theorems 1–3; §3, release and verification","supersedes":null}],"sources":[{"work":{"authors":["John Milnor"],"kind":"official_description","publication":"published","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"not_reported","ai_note":"AI use is not reported in the selected source.","artifacts":[]},"id":"milnor-poincare-description@clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","source_id":"milnor-poincare-description","title":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","owner":"John Milnor","url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","subject_scope":"The Poincaré Conjecture · official description","revision":"clay-description-observed-2026-10-12","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://www.claymath.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/06/poincare.pdf","attribution":"John Milnor","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90},{"work":{"authors":["Ziyang Qin","Yuan Liao","Ayush Khaitan","Bennett Chow"],"kind":"research_paper","publication":"preprint","publication_note":"Source-backed selection; publication and proof assessment are separate.","ai_role":"self_reported","ai_note":"Authors report automated assistance; OpenMath has not independently assessed that workflow.","artifacts":[],"published":{"value":"2026-09-27"}},"id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare@arxiv-2609.33842v1","source_id":"qin-liao-khaitan-chow-poincare","title":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","owner":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","subject_scope":"A Lean Formalization of the Hamilton–Perelman Proof of the Three-Dimensional Poincaré Conjecture","revision":"arxiv-2609.33842v1","content_sha256":null,"update_method":"Manual source review; publish new observations with immutable versions","identifier_policy":"Source revision plus exact passage or declaration; no fuzzy identity merge","observed_on":"2026-10-12","source_updated_on":null,"rights":"metadata-link","license":"Metadata, links and original OpenMath paraphrases only","terms_url":"https://arxiv.org/abs/2609.33842v1","attribution":"Ziyang Qin; Yuan Liao; Ayush Khaitan; Bennett Chow","rights_note":"Follow the original source for authoritative statements and reuse terms.","check_interval_days":90}]}}}